I have a dear friend that blogs- not about the jerk that cut her off in traffic or the cute thing one of her kids said today- but about the things that matter. We've not lived in the same town in almost 6 years and I cherish her updates as a peek into her daily life. Over the past year, she has bared her soul about the lack of community in her church, the state of orphans around the world, and lately, her views on Halloween. What's the common thread here? These are all topics she has attacked with her heart on her sleeve. We're talking a ton of passion and conviction here... all to make you think about how you are living. She will occasionally apologize for offending her audience, however she never apologizes for convicting them. I have recently prayed for more boldness in my life, and here is the result... Over the past few weeks, I have had this conversation with more and more moms, never realizing the amount of ire, judgement, and self-righteousness this topic packs. Where in the world am I going with this?? Gay marriage?? Health-care reform?? Nope...
On the second day of Christmas, God blessed me with... peace about the fat man in a red suit...
and a sweet party with new and old friends!
I grew up with my family doing Santa Claus. We trekked to the mall, sat on his lap, wrote him letters, left out milk and cookies, the whole nine yards. When my son was born 8 years ago, it never occured to me to NOT participate in this time-honored tradition. I had no idea there were families out there that spurned the jolly old man. In fact, a knew a couple of Jews that welcomed him as part of their Hanakhah celebration! Lately, however, I have been made aware of a growing number of families that are simply opting out of this seemimgly innocent Norman Rockwell-ian belief. Honestly, this idea intrigued me- why would anyone deny their child this little bit of magic in a world where they are growing up faster than we can control? I set aside some time earlier this season to talk to some of these moms and see if I didn't need to re-evaluate my stance on Ol' St Nick... As I mentioned earlier, I wasn't prepared for the self-righteousness this topic creates.
The most disturbing argument involved the idea that once your child finds out that Santa Claus- a man that they can't see, is celebrated at Christmas, and "sees you when you're sleeping... knows when you've been bad or good"- isn't real, they might start to question their belief in another Man that fits the same description... While thought provoking, I have to agree- if you only bring Jesus out in December and showcase Him as someone who will show up and make your dreams come true, then yes, you run the risk of your child equating them, and ultimately, their existence. To me, this logic is akin to homeshoolers that don't teach mythology because they don't want their children to confuse Zeus with God. If Jesus is talked about in your home, 365 days a year, as a Comforter, a Refuge, and a Redeemer, there will be no comparison! We're talking about the Creator of the Universe vs. a snappily dressed, fat FedEx guy.
The second prevailing sentiment among this camp is the idea of "lying to your children". Ok... so don't. As soon as my oldest son asked me, point blank, if Santa was real, I told him the truth. In the years since his father and I had separated and divorced, I'd received the sound advice that while my son didn't need the whole truth about our situation, I shouldn't lie to him about it. When faced with the option of being dishonest (the easy way out) and coming clean (a tough conversation), I'm glad I applied that advice to this predicament.
Last week, I was with a group of Christian moms discussing the upcoming Christmas season. The topic of "To Claus or Not" came up and I was blown away by the self-rightouesness the non-Claus camp was propagating. While I left this gathering a little ruffled, a sweet friend called me later that afternoon, worried that she was ruining her children by allowing this little bit of merriement and wonder into their young lives. Now I was mad. Everyone's entitled to their opinion- Lord knows, I have my share- and occasionally we have the opportunity to share these thoughts and reasonings with others in a respecful and non-judgemental manner. I mean, we weren't debating the merits of open marriage or puppy-killing! I was so upset that my friend had questioned not only her parenting, but also her relationship with Jesus over this nonsense.
You may find fault with my arguments- I certainly welcome your comments and opinions. Just know that I'll delete them in a heartbeat if my parenting or Christian walk are called into question :-) 'Cause that's how I roll...
So our stockings are hung by the chimney with care...
YES YES AND YES!!! Thank you, Catherine Bost for posting your heart. All FOUR of our children have believed in Santa and the two that are now teenagers are BELIEVERS in CHRIST :) and our six year old has professed Christ as well. We actually TOLD our oldest when she was in fifth grade. She cried....not because we had lied to her (we always reply with , "what do you believe?"), but because the "magic" was ending. She has taken on the roll of an older sister making it fun for her younger siblings.
ReplyDeleteWe have found that it is Christian children that become self righteous about Santa as they try to make our children feel stupid for believing. I understand the choice to NOT allow Santa, but I do wish others would respect my choice to allow him (and teach their children to avoid the subject).
You have made my day! I will refer others to this!
Good for you Catherine! I agree with EVERYTHING you say. We need to "lighten up" as a community, and enjoy the simple pleasures of life. I was raised with a creative mom who played the Santa game with me for most of my life. I loved it! Now that I have teenagers, I really miss the Santa days! Enjoy them while you can!
ReplyDeleteLike, like, like!!! I am in the minority in our weekly playgroup--seriously, I am the ONLY mom in our playgroup that allows my children to believe in Santa. I feel outcasted by it. And honestly, I'm just waiting for one of their children to break the news to my middle child (my oldest already figured it out). Luckily none of them have been self righteous about it but I always feel awkward being the only one that believes.
ReplyDeleteI may not be in your direct playgroup Laura, but as your friend I tell you, you are not alone! My children believe in Santa, they believe in fairies and they believe in God and His son Jesus!! I am not about to squelch my children's innocent fascination and creative imagination for anyone or anything! I want them to have magic in their lives! Lord knows as they grow older and have many harsh realities to face that some of that magic will disappear. I want them to hold onto it as long as possible as I want them to return to it with their own children. I can understand not liking the commercialism of the holiday, but not liking the belief of Santa and the notion that it would make your child a non-believer!!! Ha! Bah hum bug I say to those who buy into this!
ReplyDeleteThank you Catherine for a wonderful blog! You are a wonderful lady and I am glad to have you as my friend!! :o) Merry Christmas!!
I don't remember who it was, but someone told me about their "middle of the road" stance and we've tried to do it as well.....we've told kids about who St. Nick was, what he stood for, where he found his Hope.....and said something like, "and still, all over the world, children love to pretend that St. Nick still comes and secretly brings presents. Isn't it fun to pretend that?" That's basically all I've ever said for 9 years but I think this year is the first one that my 9 year old "gets it" and she's not spilling the beans. She thinks it's still fun to pretend with the younger ones. She isn't sad but she had fun with it while it lasted. We do live in a place with less Christmas-celebrating people, so Santa and elves aren't as "in your face" as they were in Atlanta.
ReplyDeleteCatherine you're a good mom!!! Wish we could have coffee sometime. Don't you want to take a trip to Berkeley????? Where open marriages rise -and fall- proudly? Where old ladies wear dreads and children never wear hair bows? :)